Uh Oh, Zillow!
The most accurate real estate listing sites will always be in the local multiple listing sites (MLS), as this is where data begins. When I meet with a seller(s) to ‘list’ their home, that means the property will then be entered into the MLS system which is a public website for folks to see listings for land, homes, condos and multi-unit properties. Few commercial properties are put on an MLS for public view but may appear just on that firm’s website. But not all websites for real estate firms are great. Most will have a link to MLS listings for all companies who have listings in their local MLS, bio’s of their agents and broker and possibly helpful hints to buy and sell, links to favorite vendors, etc. The system has been around since the late 1800’s. It really got a serious start in San Diego in 1885, when real estate brokers shared listing info via runners who took horses, trolleys, and later cars to deliver info back and forth between brokerages.
Fast forward to the early 2000’s when some execs at Expedia created the real estate company Zillow, with the intent to provide property data and give instant home evaluations called ‘Zestimates’. A few years after launching the site it created the Zillow Mortgage Marketplace and then started and stopped their ‘iBuying’ program where they would purchase your home online. The real estate market was smokin’ hot in 2018 when the company made online offers to home owners but found that soon turned into a big losing part of the brand and was shut down as the market became soft. Their website remains full of information but as a top selling broker, I can say that Zillow Zestimates are notoriously wrong and I’m constantly hearing both complaints about that from clients or am having to give clients the real data that shows their property isn’t worth the millions of dollars that Zestimate gave them.
Zillow right now is in big trouble with the Feds. A new class action lawsuit claims that Zillow eavesdrops on client communications to catch their Zillow agents who have recommend lenders that aren’t part of the Zillow Mortgage Marketplace, requires its special ‘Flex’ agents to meet quotas and cherry picks highly qualified buyers for mortgages but offers higher loan interest rates and inaccurate disclosures. These would be RESPA violations wherein Zillow (according to the lawsuit) is “illegally both giving and receiving a thing of value related to referrals and receiving payments that is not in exchange for completing the property transaction.” The complaint has been amended after a separate class action suit accuses the real estate firm of using kickbacks to boost its mortgage. There are also accusations that defendants have made claiming RICO violations, in that the company runs a criminal enterprise of sorts of fraud, extortion, etc.
We shall see what happens with these lawsuits in the coming new year. HAPPY HOLIDAYS!
